Rethinking the World

From P2P Foundation Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

* Book: Rethinking the World. By Peter Pogany. iUniverse, 2006

URL = https://integralpermaculture.wordpress.com/peter-pogany/

Description

Integral Permaculture:

“In 2006 Pogany’s major work was published: Rethinking the World, “the result of several years of full-time, independent, transdisciplinary research.”

In Rethinking the World, Pogany delved deep into his understanding of history as a thermodynamic process, and named his approach New Historical Materialism, informed by Hegel and Marx, but quite distinctly different, and heavily influenced also by Nicholas Georgescu Roegen‘s ideas about the relationship between thermodynamics and economics, as outlined in his classic treatise on “The Entropy Law and the Economic Process,” and by Ilya Prigogine’s theories about dissipative structures, order out of chaos, and the irreversability of time (i.e. Order Out of Chaos and The End of Certainty).

From the blurb about Pogany’s book:

“The still expanding human biomass and mindlessly pursued economic expansion are straining against the planet’s physical limits. Oil! Energy! Ecology! Growing vulnerabilities in hyperlinked national economies! The transformation of the current global system, “mixed economy/weak multilateralism,” into a radically new one, “two-level economy/strong multilateralism,” looks like the only way to avoid drifting toward extinction…

History has recorded two distinct global systems thus far: “laissez faire/metal money,” which spanned most of the 19th century and lasted until the outbreak of World War I, and “mixed economy/weak multilateralism,” which began after 1945 and exists today. The period between the two systems, 1914-1945, was a chaotic transition. This evolutionary pulsation is well known to students of thermodynamics. It corresponds to the behavior of expanding and complexifying material systems. The exhaustion of oil and other natural resources is pushing the world toward a third global system that may be called “two-level economy/strong multilateralism.” It will be impossible to get there without a new chaotic transition. No repeated warnings, academic advice, moral advocacy, inspired reforms, or political leadership can provide a shortcut around it. But if it took “1914-1945″ to make a relatively minor adjustment in the global order, what will it take to make a major one?” (https://integralpermaculture.wordpress.com/peter-pogany/?)


Summary

Chapter 6

Dave McLeod:

"This past week I've been re-reading the very long chapter 6 from his 2006 book, Rethinking the World, on "The Brain's Central Role in Cultural Evolution." "Each global system creates its characteristic behavior, connected with a lexicon, a socioeconomically induced emotional profile, an ethic, a Weltanschauung, and a mentality. These are physically 'imprinted' in brains and endure roughly as long as the global system does." [a number of these words found in the Glossary in the back of the book - a very helpful guide in defining about 80 terms that Pogany uses in unique ways]

One way Pogany describes cultural evolution and world history is as a "neuropsychiatric healing process" (p. 153). But this healing process is thrown into doubt during chaotic transitions when the collective mind begins searching for the blueprint for the next stable condition.

That we are in such a chaotic transition right now is evidenced by what is being called "the meaning crisis" or "the epistemic crisis," or "the post-truth era." We are floundering in trying to find common ground with one another. As a result, we see more conflicts between in-groups and out-groups; more conflicts within in-groups; more disarray as previously aligned groups split apart and what we consider to be "left" or "right" becomes confused and switched. And hence increased conflict and finger pointing and muddled thinking, as we can see around these issues of CRT, cancel culture, conspiracy theory, generational conflicts, etc.


Pogany:

- "Socioeconomic evolution is unthinkable without 'experimental behavior' that fails miserably at the beginning. In addition to the individually chosen 'voluntarily experimental behavior,' there is 'involuntary, group experimental behavior.' Some alternatives to the defunct world order (GS1) made it into statehood during the global transformation, coaxing out or forcing accommodative responses. What seemed normal and permanent in the species-wide self-destructive search phase turned out to be failed historical experiments, to personal disadvantage on a massive scale" (p. 155).


In regards to the title of the book, "Rethinking the World":

- "From the point of view of the world as a whole, the multiple, simultaneous efforts to determine meanings produced confusion. The world was thinking amidst its self-destructive systemlessness; it was rethinking itself... The establishment of the lexicon begins before its presence is universally recognized. Some of its remnants linger after it is gone... Through the nested layers of adaptations of the global system, the lexicon becomes diffused and concealed in the practice of daily life... But on the whole, the global system's text tends to make people forget about the historical nature and the mortality of the global system. Radical, effective reality clouds the underlying absolute reality of transcience. ... Of course, lexicons have never been assembled. But there is no need for a fully completed and bound handbook. (We know that we live by 'social contracts' even if none of us remembers signing one.)" (p. 169-170)


Wrapping up chapter 6:

- "Macrohistory suggests that only a new global transformation will be able to clear the road for a future that does not roll out the red carpet to cultural devolution. What gives us pause is that, if it took "1914-1945" (circa 70 million dead, many millions maimed, and the hardships of the Great Depression) to move the world from the most primitive form of socioeconmic self-organization to a more ordered one (a relatively minor qualitative adjustment), it staggers the imagination to contemplate what it might entail to go from 'here' to the 'world-as-self.' (p. 182-183)."


Excerpt

Peter Pogany on the New Historical Materialism

page 3:

"The 'old' (Marxist) historical materialism cannot fill the need, not only because it flunked history (and economics), but also because its 'materialism' became superannuated. Its 'matter' vanished into warps of space-time; gutless assemblages of shuffling, trembling particles that behave like waves if they so please; probability clouds caught up in a cosmic sequel to the Big Bang. Nineteenth century science believed that matter was knowable through the accumulation of experimental knowledge. There was Darwin, organic chemistry, the never ceasing succession of miracles produced by the emerging technical civilization. "Poor Aristotle," the scientists of the era thought, with his intertwined form and substance; earth, air, water, and fire. (Excuse me?) And now there is "poor Marx" with his querulous and, in retrospect, pathetic berating of Hegel, who dared to consider "the life processes of the human brain, i.e., the process of thinking" the central issue of historical evolution, when it should have been clear to anyone with an iota of modern analytical common sense that thoughts were external to the objective reality of matter. Contemporary "brain science" could not disagree more. Thoughts and emotions, and hence, convictions, have become perceivable in terms of biology, chemistry, and physics...

We shall demonstrate that the emerging conflict between the expanding human empire - a hyper-cyborg Leviathan-and the Earth's material limitations may yet lead to a new beginning on a higher plateau. The socioeconomic evolution of the past two centuries revealed steady direction and the ability to reorganize on the global scale. The genes, the physical carriers of biological heredity, evidently have emergent properties. They have proven to be capable of going through stages of supra-individual, planet-wide arrangements, while preserving the germ of the next, more complex one. If the species' self-organization succeeds in renewing itself in a superior edition, the generations living in those times might look back at the currently expiring age of petroleum and self-hypnosis about the possibility of infinite growth in a closed space with dismayed comprehension....

In new historical materialism, a theory that we shall introduce in the ensuing pages, only the new remains unchanged. Rethinking the world and its future is a recurring necessity, fraught as it may be with inadvertent subjectivity or manipulative bias. Humanity's impending violent argument with itself is of momentous concern. If the race has further significant evolutionary potential, it will have to equip itself with a shared mega-perspective on its past and future that is physically relevant and has a high moral content. For that, the global society will have to absorb the postmodern era's lessons on pluralism and equality, but will also have to abandon its epistemic defeatism and its craving for the acid bath of nihilistic disunity.

...Could the mind's keen awareness and huge information-processing capability - the individual's virtually unlimited reservoir of behavioral alternatives - make a difference? Could it reduce the extent and duration of the suffering? There is no clear answer. The observer is entangled with the observed, putting a limit on the externality and independence of the observation. This means some rancor or enthusiasm here and there, according to the context. Our solace for theis unavoidable shortcoming is that these biases are neurophysiological entities. They are alive in many with the potential to survive and evolve into pro-active convictions."

(https://www.iuniverse.com/BookStore/BookDetails/139712-Rethinking-the-World)


Discussion

More on Pogany's vision for Global System 3, from his 2006 book,"Rethinking the World"

David MacLeod:

"Gradual and smooth transition to a renewable resource-based techno-economic space cannot substitute for global transformation/chaotic transition because the accomplished transition implies conversion at the macroscopic, mesoscopic, and microscopic levels at once. The world will need a global approach to resource management and environmental control with appropriate authority and means to harmonize national preferences (macroscopic alteration). At the mesoscopic level, national governments will have to ensure steadfast and longsighted resource management and environmental control; they will have to be equipped with administrative tools to guide their economies. They will have to provide a framework for local economic initiatives (cantons). Microscopically, the individual as a consumer will have to develop a taste for (or recover the joy of) long-lasting (slowly depreciating), high-quality products. As a producer, the individual will have to become less competitive and more cooperative; it will have to develop disinterest in extraordinary wealth and personal power; i.e. the importance of the canonical scale of socioeconomic status will have to decline. (If a GS3-typical persona were alive today, it would probably look at greedy businessmen with the same understanding and empathy that contemporary adults feel when they see children play 'make-believe'). As both consumers and producers, people will have to become conscious of the environment and the need to conserve material and energy resources. The business firm (the typical association of producers under GS1 and GS2) will have to reinvent itself under hard material and energy constraints. It will have to operate in a marketplace that neither encourages nor rewards ruthless competition; it will have to extend its field of view." (pages 211-212)

On page 215, Pogany states that “the main aspiration of a post-GS2 system will have to be the control of global and, hence, national economic activity levels in full consideration of the material constraints that affect the entire human population.” And yet, GS2 must expire, and so he writes on page 216 that “In practical terms, GS2 is considered beyond help if its domestic and multilateral institutions need to be suspended for whatever reason, and/or alternatives to replace them pop up. The suspension of the old and the entry of the new may take the form of widespread local initiatives in energy production and environmental protection. Such a phenomen would defacto presage the two-level economy (GS3). Cantonization may begin when high gasoline prices make more people stay in their immediate environs, encouraging the development of economic neighborhoods and increasing the social and cultural importance of grassroots communities… The scope and intensity of efforts directed at the elimination of the socioeconomic safety net in the vanguard and matching repulsion in the political sphere are indications of the global system’s decay. The greater the clash of wills, the more likely that we are in “it.”

“…The main concern is the length and intensity of the coming period of macro-historic instability… It is more than likely that such subglobal escape routes through internecine manipulation, domination, and conquest will be entertained, delaying unified rationalization and the development of an appropriate strategy to redirect cultural evolution. But no one can tell for how long… Humankind should consider itself lucky if economic problems, severe as they may be, sufficed to shock its ranks into unity of thought and action.”

Pogany proceeds to discusses some complex economic equations to determine a "global somatic/extrasomatic transformation curve" that could be used to allocate scarce resources in balance with required population levels. Page 218: “To avoid decline and extinction, the world will have to become a single decision maker. It must develop the corresponding institutions and adjust individual conduct. The propositions that (i) a ‘transformation curve’ between population and physical output will have to be identified; (ii) that once this happens there will be a search for the optimal location on it; and (iii) that this will necessitate the weighing of alternatives lead to this conclusion.

“…there is a trade-off between global population and world material output at the full use of the Earth’s carrying capacity… The descendancy will be able to augment physical output only if it sees to the reduction of the population, or vice versa. If it drifts toward the maximum material wealth, it will need to ‘push’ the level of population toward its minimum; and, if it embraces the ‘more the merrier’ philosophy to its extreme, it will barely subsist…

“There are, of course, an infinite number of intermediate combinations between Country Club Palace (very high output with very low population) and Malthus Point (very low output and very high population). One that is closer to the second but much less harsh is a world in which basic human needs such as food, shelter, clothing, economic infrastructure (public utilities, transportation and communication systems) and social infrastructure (education, health care, law and order) are fully met. In short, meeting these needs guarantees decent working conditions and living standards…. To secure an opportunity for ‘sustainable development,’ cultural evolution will have to be globally managed.” (pp. 220-221)

In the following chapter ("The Future Mechanism of Global Decision-Making"), he fleshes these ideas out. “A team of international experts, leaning on the planet’s entire academic infrastructure, will have to construct the global somatic/extrasomatic transformation curve. This concept is likely to become vital for latter-day generations.” (p. 222)

The next chapter (“Telos, Saga, and Homo Novus”) has a 12 page section on The GS3 Avatar, which includes a section in which Pogany shares more on the concept of strong multilateralism, which comes in conjunction with localism:

“Strong multilateralism is not the rule of a Pontificus Dominus (Kim Jon Il gone global), disguised as an overworked, kindhearted UN Secretary General. It implies an institutional framework for pro-active international cooperation and coordination. Even the replacement of ‘conspicuous consumption’ with ‘conspicuous altruism’ will not turn humans into termites. As far as consumption is concerned, there will ‘have to be’ a shift from quantity to quality; to meaningful variety and refinements. (Economic theory has shown that the increase in the variety of products and improvements in product quality are conceivable without growth in overall economic output or in population.) Local, cantonal activities to safeguard and enhance living standards will probably gain in importance at the expense of the competitive cross-hauling of near perfect substitutes and the global franchise. (Good-bye expensive milky slush of stretched coffee beans; so long cheap, health-sapping mystery-meat patties from the assembly line.) Education, leisure, and joy might move to center stage. If not the end, GS3 could be the beginning of the end for poverty, economically motivated criminality, self-degradation through drug use, and the constant and pervasive worry about tomorrow.

“Get comfortable. No one wants to see the individual turn into a faceless, genderless global communard living in glassy falansters, unable to tell where his or her organism ends and where its cybernetic prolongation begins. Take a deep breath and imagine life without multitasking, touch-and-go aggressiveness, all the human-made traps for reciprocal deceptions and selfdeceptions. The ancient Greek ideal of people cultivating their minds and bodies, living in a global polis of limpid order and Apollonian measure, patience, courtesy, and harmony in human relations might just become reality, and this time around for everybody, not just for ‘free men.’ Fulfilling the dream of so many thinkers and believers through the ages, entropy may not be the dreaded archfiend after all. This is the positive way of looking beyond the approaching chaotic interlude, considering the new world order a qualitatively altered state of mind that allows for the continuation of progress seen in cultural evolution.

“Utopia? Wishful eschatology? Touchy-feely, quixotic One Worldism? No, Homo novus follows directly from dismissing as groundless the augury that the good fortunes of homo sapiens are inevitably over. Not seeing mankind turn into a diffident collection of vital-sign-exhibiting fossils, begging on their knees for reprieve and forgiveness from forces they no longer try to understand, equals GS3 in the context of self-perception (Saga), foresight (Telos), and long-term optimization (global transformation curve). For all that, the representative brain will have to reprogram itself in a big way.

“As Darwin eloquently noted, complexity of a higher order appears as supernatural if we are not privy to its evolutionary history.” (pp. 267-269)

Pogany’s comments about the next chaotic transition and consciousness change, from the opening Summary of Havoc:

"What will it take to go from considering tightened modes of multilateral governance a monstrous dystopia to people around the world on their knees begging for a planetary Magna Carta that is more detailed, focused and enforceable than the United Nations Charter of 1945? It will take nothing less than a mutation in consciousness, as outlined by the Swiss thinker, Jean Gebser (1905-1973). But a mutation of the implied magnitude amounts to nothing less than a break with centuries of ingrained habits, values, and expectations. It is simply inconceivable without the hard fate of macrohistoric turmoil.

“The world lives suspended over an abyss. To appreciate its depth one must recognize that whereas '1914-1945' was the price paid for a mere historic adaptation, the impending turbulence must yield a transformation of evolutionary significance. The argument that the potentially disruptive violence of such a difficult situation may be diffused by an arbitrary lengthening of its time falters on the already binding physical constraints to economic weight gain. “The new chaotic transition will start sometime between now [2013] and the 2030s; and, barring a miracle, it will turn the world into a charnel house on a scale that will make the destruction, gore, and horrific imbecilities of '1914-1945' look like a mere prologue. But the will to live must triumph in the fullness of time. Once this defining, dark chapter is closed and the world discovers itself, there are many reasons to believe in the rebirth of an all-embracing, well-founded Hegelian optimism." - "Havoc: Thy Name is 21st Century" (p. ix-x)

For more on how Pogany related his ideas around GS3 to Jean Gebser’s structures of consciousness, an excerpt from a blog posted in Oct. 2013:

“The current world order cannot deliver long-term sustainability on a planetary scale. By design, it is incapable of recognizing humanity’s thermodynamic reality. A new form of global selforganization is needed and it is probably waiting in the wings.

What does all this have to do with Gebser? Wait, we’re getting there!

According to him, each consciousness structure coincided with distinctive socioeconomic conditions: The archaic, with primitive hunting, fishing, and gathering; the magical, with more advanced versions of the same activities within increasingly complex social schemes centering on the horde; the mythical, which was characterized by agriculture; the mental by industry coming to dominance.

The collision between our civilization and its ecological constraints, along with a likely historic crisis of epic proportions, may be regarded as the struggle of integral-arational consciousness (Gebser’s “fifth structure”) to deprive overblown rationality (the deficient phase of mental consciousness) from its current preeminence.

What will the parameters of the new global system be? Regardless of how correctly or incorrectly one may characterize it, any consistent attempt to find an answer must conclude that a radically new social, economic, and political organization will be needed. The precondition of saving the world from itself is a mutation of the average individual consciousness. It will favor cooperation over competition; acquiescence over indifference; responsible sociability over isolation; integrative open-mindedness over stubborn, perspectival dogmatism, altruism over extrasomatic hedonism.” - “Living Under the Dome,” Oct. 2, 2013, http://blog.gebser.net/

(https://storage.ning.com/topology/rest/1.0/file/get/4565377457?)