Between Copyleft and Copyfarleft

From P2P Foundation Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

* Article: Between Copyleft and Copyfarleft: Advance reciprocity for the commons. By Miguel Said Vieira & Primavera De Filippi. Journal of Peerproduction, Issue 4: Value and currency.

URL = https://peerproduction.net/issues/issue-4-value-and-currency/invited-comments/between-copyleft-and-copyfarleft-advance-reciprocity-for-the-commons/


Description

"Licensing debates abound in the “free culture” academic discussion (see, i.a., Downes, 2009; Hill, 2005; Lemos, 2010; Netpop Research, 2009; UNESCO OER Community, 2011), but we believe much of it suffers from one of two problems. First, restricting themselves to a purely technical, legalistic approach; this kind of approach is important and necessary for improving licenses, but it is not sufficient to deal with the social impacts and ramifications of such licenses. Second, adopting a dualistic and overly antagonistic approach, particularly with regard to the debate on commercial usages. This debate touches important aspects of the licensing discussions, but it frequently stalemates (due to its polarized character) before it is possible to make significant advances in deepening our knowledge about these issues, and coordinating efforts for improving the knowledge commons.

The copyfarleft licensing model is a concrete proposal related to the commercial usages debate. It suggests one way to improve on “non-commercial clauses”, arguably making them more effective in reducing negative social impacts, such as wage labour being exploited in building the commons. We believe it is an interesting contribution that mostly avoids the problems mentioned above, but also has its potential drawbacks. This position paper comments on them (as well as on some merits of this model), and proposes an alternative or complementary model that attempts to solve some of those drawbacks.

Free culture licenses had as their most relevant predecessor the GPL (GNU General Public License), a free software license which makes no distinction regarding commercial and noncommercial usages. This distinction first appeared in some Creative Commons licenses, with the introduction of the noncommercial clause which only allows unauthorized use for noncommercial exploitation. While these licenses are widely used, there has been a large debate regarding what exactly constitutes a commercial use, and whether the noncommercial clause is indeed likely to ultimately benefit the knowledge commons.

The copyfarleft licensing scheme proposed by Dmytri Kleiner (2007)1 stipulates similar restrictions to the noncommercial copyleft model, but provides additional conditions on the kind of usages which are effectively permitted under the license. Specifically, while all noncommercial usages are allowed (subject to the restrictions imposed by the copyleft clause), the copyfarleft model distinguish between commercial usages enacted by worker-owned collectives, cooperatives, or any other institution where profits are distributed (equally) amongst all workers, and those enacted by commercial entities or corporations whose businesses are exclusively based on the exploitation of wage labour. While the former kind of commercial exploitation is generally allowed under the copyfarleft licensing scheme (as opposed to what is usually the case in noncommercial licenses), the latter kinds remain prohibited – although they can still be negotiated outside the scope of the license.

This licensing scheme lies, thus, somewhere between a standard copyleft license (as in a Creative Commons CC-BY-SA) and a noncommercial copyleft license (as in a CC-BY-NC-SA). The reason underlying this choice is that, while, on the one hand, a standard copyleft license allows corporate entities to exploit and profit from the labour employed in building the commons, without having to give back to them –something which Kleiner points out as highly problematic, and particularly so outside of the realm of software production–2 on the other hand, a noncommercial license precludes even commons-based producers (such as many of the workers-owned enterprises) from commercially exploiting a work (and as Kleiner argues, this can also be counterproductive for the transformative potential of these licenses)."

More information

Bibliography:

Bauwens, M. (2005a). The political economy of peer production. CTheory, 1.

Bauwens, M. (2005b). P2P and Human Evolution: Peer to peer as the premise of a new mode of civilization. Ensaio, rascunho, 1.

Bauwens, M. (2012). From the theory of Peer Production to the production of Peer Production theory, in Journal of Peer Production, Issue 1, July 2012.

Benkler, Y. (2002). “Coase’s Penguin, or, Linux and The Nature of the Firm”.Yale Law Journal, 369-446.

Benkler, Y. (2006). The wealth of networks: How social production transforms markets and freedom. Yale University Press.

De Laat, P. B. (2005). Copyright or copyleft?: An analysis of property regimes for software development. Research Policy, 34(10), 1511-1532.

Downes, S., 2009. The Role of Open Educational Resources in Personal Learning. Open Educational Resources: Innovation, Research and Practice, p. 207.

Goss, A. K. (2007). Codifying a Commons: Copyright, Copyleft, and the Creative Commons Project. Chi.-Kent L. Rev., 82, 963.

Hill, B.M., 2005. Freedom’s Standard Advanced? Mute, 2(1), pp. 46–53. Also available at <http://www.metamute.org/editorial/articles/freedoms-standard-advanced>

Kleiner, D. (2007). Copyfarleft and Copyjustright. Available at <http://www.metamute.org/editorial/articles/copyfarleft-and-copyjustright>

Kleiner, D. (2010). The telekommunist manifesto. Institute of Network Cultures

Lemos, R., 2010. Legal Commons and Social Commons: Creativity and Innovation in the Global Peripheries. In D. Bourcier et al., eds. Intelligent Multimedia. Series in Legal Information and Communication Technologies. Florence: European Press Academic Publishing, p. 175. Available at: http://www.academia.edu/download/30324155/ccibook_printedversion_intelligentmultimedia1.pdf [Accessed July 24, 2013].

Meretz, S. (2008). Copyfarleft & a critique. Available at <http://www.metamute.org/editorial/articles/copyfarleft-critique>

Netpop Research, 2009. Defining “Noncommercial”: A Study of How the Online Population Understands “Noncommercial Use.” Available at: http://wiki.creativecommons.org/Defining_Noncommercial.

UNESCO OER Community & Downes, S., 2011. The OER debate, in Full. Available at: http://openaccess.uoc.edu/webapps/o2/handle/10609/7301 [Accessed July 24, 2013].

Stallman, R. (1998). Copyleft: pragmatic idealism.

Toner, A. (2007). “Copyfarleft: An Anarchist Gema?”. Available at <http://knowfuture.wordpress.com/2007/11/22/copyfarleft-an-anarchist-gema/>.