Towards a Distributive Politics of Attention

From P2P Foundation Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search


Characteristics

Peter Tornberg:

"A distributive politics of attention would begin by asking three related questions: who receives attention, who has the power to allocate it, and who bears the costs generated by competition for it. The first concerns visibility: which people, problems and claims enter public view. The second concerns power: who gets to design the systems through which visibility is allocated. The third concerns externalities: who pays when the competition for attention rewards misinformation, harassment, political extremism or the degradation of shared public institutions.

...

At present, much of this allocative power sits with a handful of private platforms, which design the systems through which visibility is measured, ranked and distributed. Decisions with enormous consequences for public life are embedded in proprietary systems optimized according to privately chosen objectives, often poorly aligned with public interest."

(https://informationaldemocracy.substack.com/p/distributive-politics-of-attention)


Discussion

Peter Tornberg:

"In the weakly regulated industrial capitalism of the nineteenth century, competition produced child labor, punishing working hours, dangerous factories, starvation wages and polluted cities. These outcomes did not arise because individual employers wanted them; they were imposed by market competition. A factory owner who shortened the working day or paid substantially higher wages bore the costs individually, while the benefits were dispersed across society. What was desirable collectively could be irrational individually, and thus disciplined away by market competition.

The response was to change the rules of competition. Child labor did not go out of fashion because factory owner became morally better, but because regulation changed the competitive environment so that socially destructive behavior no longer conferred the same advantage. Politics altered the selection pressures of the market.

We should begin asking the same questions about attention.

The distribution of attention is therefore also a distribution of political power. It shapes which issues become publicly visible, which actors can build constituencies, whose claims enter public debate and which problems disappear from view. Some actors can command enormous amounts of attention while others struggle to obtain any at all; still others possess the power to determine the conditions under which everybody competes for it.

At present, much of this allocative power sits with a handful of private platforms, which design the systems through which visibility is measured, ranked and distributed. Decisions with enormous consequences for public life are embedded in proprietary systems optimized according to privately chosen objectives, often poorly aligned with public interest.

A distributive politics of attention would begin by asking three related questions: who receives attention, who has the power to allocate it, and who bears the costs generated by competition for it. The first concerns visibility: which people, problems and claims enter public view. The second concerns power: who gets to design the systems through which visibility is allocated. The third concerns externalities: who pays when the competition for attention rewards misinformation, harassment, political extremism or the degradation of shared public institutions.

A distributive politics of attention is not a demand for equal attention. The relevant political question is how institutional rules structure access to visibility, concentrations of allocative power, and the incentives created by competition for it. Some claims need scrutiny; some events matter more than others; some speakers have more knowledge or democratic legitimacy; and much of what is said can safely remain obscure, and not all individuals or communities always benefit from attention. The political question is who gets to define the rules and boundaries of its allocation, under the recognition of how it will impact society and democracy. The point is to make the principles governing visibility publicly contestable rather than leaving them as the proprietary optimization functions of private platforms.

The question is how the distribution of attention can be made to encourage more prosocial and democratic forms of politics.

What costs should competitors be allowed to impose on the shared information environment? What should remain protected from competition? What kinds of political behavior should simply cease to pay? How much power to command collective attention should any private actor be allowed to accumulate?

These are distributive questions because they concern not simply how much attention different actors receive, but how the power and costs generated by the attention economy are allocated across society.

So yes: we need a distributive politics of attention. We need it because attention has become commodified as a source of economic and political power, because the rules governing its allocation shape our politics, and because those rules are presently designed largely by private companies according to objectives that appear incompatible with democracy.

We are unlikely to return to a world in which public attention is amorphous, unmeasured and difficult to monetize. The toothpaste is out of the tube: attention has been quantified, priced and turned into a basis for competition. The question is no longer whether an attention economy should exist, but what rules should govern it.

Industrial capitalism eventually forced democratic societies to confront a similar problem. The response was not simply to ask individual capitalists to behave better. It was to build institutions that changed what competition rewarded, prohibited and permitted.

We have barely begun that political project for attention.

If democracy once had to learn how to govern markets for labor, land and money, it must now learn how to govern the market for attention."

(https://informationaldemocracy.substack.com/p/distributive-politics-of-attention)