= alternatives to the proprietary Slack software
Directory created by Danyl Strype of Disintermedia, now maintained here. Original at https://web.archive.org/web/20181208131734/https://www.coactivate.org/projects/disintermedia/slacking-off/
- 1 Introduction
- 2 A few questions to help you decide what to replace Slack with:
- 3 Potential replacements
- 4 Stalled or Abandoned?
- 5 Abandonware
- 6 Sources
When commons stewardship organisations like CreativeCommons started to use Slack in place of IRC, along with open source projects like Mozilla, this was justified on the basis that people didn't have to use the proprietary (and some say awful) Slack client. Instead, they could use their choice of app by using Slack's IRC or XMPP bridges, which allowed Slack to enclose organisations that would otherwise never have gone there. Now that those bridges have been removed, they're locked in, because Slack has their chat history, a classic bait-and-switch tactic. This page is about liberating software your team could use in place of Slack. Apps within each section are listed in alphabetical order.
A few questions to help you decide what to replace Slack with:
- do you use Slack mainly to communicate with a team, or as more of a chat-based social network?
- are you in a position to self-host a team chat package, or are you only interested in using hosted services?
- do you use Slack mainly for realtime chat, or asynchronous messages, or equally for both?
- is voice and video mission critical, or do you only need text chat?
- how important is your chat history? Is it an essential archive of your institutional memory, like mailing list archives? Is it ephemeral, like idling in IRC, with your team usually summarizing Slack chat in docs on a wiki or whatever?
- do you want it to allow federation between different servers, or are you happy having all participants set up an account on one server (yours or a third-party host) with backups?
- is email integration of interest, or are you all drowning in email and not wanting email delivery/ replies as a option? (I'm guessing it's not that important since Slack has no email bridge, but...)
This page aims to offer a wide range of possible replacements for Slack, all of which publish their source code under a liberating license that respects their users' software freedom. Some of the projects listed may be experimental, which will be mentioned where known, others may have been abandoned since the page was last updated. Updates and feedback on testing experiences is welcome, and will be used to improve the usefulness of the listings on this page.
Chat-like Slack replacements
Key criteria for being included here as a possible Slack replacement is supporting realtime text chat, and having at least one way of using it in on the web, so its usable by anyone with a web browser. But like Slack itself, many of these projects can also be used via desktop and mobile apps. Also, some of these projects may integrate with voice/ video chat systems (See Free Code Chat Apps for a table of chat apps, their features, and how they work).
If what you're look for is a private chat space for your team, or your organization, rather than a chat-based social network, one of these is probably your best option:
- Rocket.Chat ("MIT"): Demo available at open.rocket.chat. Messages can be edited after sending. Threaded like mailing lists. Supports voice messages within chats.
- Wire (GPLv3): Demo available at app.wire.com. Impressive list of features including full end-to-end encryption, disposable messages, message editing, and voice and video conferencing. Has a web app, as well as apps that run on all the major OS. Downsides: desktops apps use Electron (so no 32-bit support) and will probably continue to do so for some time. Self-hosted Wire servers can't yet do server>server federation with each other, although this is said to be in the works.
- Zulip (Apache 2.0): Demo available at chat.zulip.org. Gratis hosting for free code and open source projects. Threaded like mailing lists. Has apps for desktop and mobile and can be used in third-party apps like Ferdi. Downsides: uses Electron for desktop apps (see entry on Wire).
If a chat-based social network is what you're looking for, where you can easily connect with other people involved in free code development and other commons projects, one of these could be for you:
- Element (formerly Riot, Apache 2.0): Connects with any chat server using matrix, a federated communication protocol. There are other matrix apps in development but as of 2020 none of these are as feature complete. Direct chats and invite-only chats are end-to-end encrypted by default and encryption can be turned on in other rooms. Messages can be edited after sending. Element also offers desktop and mobile apps for all major OS; GNU-Linux, MacOS, Windows, Android, and iThings. Downsides: uses Electron for desktop apps (see entry on Wire).
- fediverse: not an app or a service, but rather a federation of services (or "instances") each running one of a range of apps that can federate with each other. Each app uses one or more of the shared standards/ protocols for social networking on the web, the most popular being ActivityPub. The original fediverse apps were designed more as a micro-blogging network (eg Mastodon, Pleroma), but can be used for private team discussions using Direct Messages, and particularly for discussion between teams around solving shared problems. More recently, multimedia apps like PixelFed (images), PeerTube (videos), and FunkWhale (music) have joined the fediverse.
- Gitter ("MIT"): The hosted instance at Gitter.im is run by Element and free to use. "Slack ... has limitations for large communities and public usage. All of Gitter’s public conversation history is completely unlimited, open, archived and indexed by popular search engines, contributing the public knowledge base of the internet". GitLab announced they were acquiring Gitter in 2017 and then sold it on to Element in 2020. Over the course of 2021-22, Gitter will be migrated to the matrix protocol (see the entry above on Element).
- Kontalk (various licenses): "Kontalk is run by a community of volunteers offering servers and splitting costs among them", all software used in both the XMPP servers and clients they distribute is free code. Full end-to-end encryption for both client-to-server and server-to-server channels. Uses phone numbers as user IDs, like Signal, but in Kontalk's case this is known to potentially compromise user privacy.
- Spectrum (New BSD): Demo linked on the home page. Threaded like mailing lists. Project member Max said in 2018: "threads and communities are completely public by default! They are fully indexed on search engines and everybody can find them". Messages can be edited after sending. No plans to make the package easier self-host, although it is possible. No plans to support federation with other instances of Spectrum or other software. Originally developed by Space Program Inc. Has since been acquired by Microsoft via GitHub.
- The Lounge ("MIT"): Web client for IRC. Can be used on servers like Freenode, which has hosted chat rooms for free code projects since 1998.
The eXtensible Messaging and Presence Protocol was originally designed for one-to-one Instant Messaging (IM), basically a way to see if a friend or coworker is online and available to chat, and send short text messages back and forth in realtime. It can also support chat rooms using Multi-User Chat (MUC), like an Internet Relay Chat (IRC) channel, but unlike IRC, you don't have to be on the XMPP server hosting the chat room to participate. Slack's stated mission is to provide team communications, not casual watercooler chat, and rose to its current popularity due to a perceived lack of team-specific features and user-friendliness in XMPP and IRC software. That said, if your team only started using Slack because "everyone is there", and you're comfortable with choosing an XMPP app with Slack-a-like features that may not work with all other XMPP servers and clients, these web-based apps may be of interest:
- JSXC "(MIT"): web client for XMPP. Has been used by some Diaspora pods to provide a realtime chat feature.
- Libervia (AGPLv3): Web client for Salut à Toi (AGPLv3), an experiment with building a federated blogging and forum network app on XMPP. Demo site at libervia.org. The developers are also working on an Android app called Cagou (AGPLv3).
- Movim (AGPLv3): An experiment with building a federated social network app on XMPP. Also available as an Android app.
- Xabber (AGPLv3): A web client that aims to support all the new features added in recent extensions to XMPP. Native app for Android also available (GPLv3).
Forum-like Slack Replacements
Maybe you found yourself using Slack because you needed a comms tool that has a better set of team features than most email lists, but you actually find realtime chat distracting rather than useful. Key criteria for being included here as a possible Slack replacement is supporting asynchronous text chat, and having at least one way of using it in on the web, so its usable by anyone with a web browser. But like Slack itself, many of these projects can also be used via desktop and mobile apps.
- Discourse (GPLv2+): Demo link on homepage. Web forums with full email integration, so users can receive and reply to posts by email. Developed by an VC-funded company called the Civilized Discourse Construction Kit Inc, that is incorporated in the USA.
- Hylo (AGPLv3): A web-based community discussion platform that is being ported to the Holochain hosting platform. Acquired in 2019 by Holo, developers of Holochain.
- Loomio (AGPLv3): Demo available at Loom.io. Supports both discussions and decision-making using a range of poll types. Granular public/ private settings for each groups, subgroups, threads, and poll. Full email integration, so users can receive and reply to posts by email, and participate in polls. Developed by an Aotearoa (NZ) based worker-owned coop that is a member of the Enspiral network.
Possible Alternatives to Slack-a-likes
These are text chat tools that don't have a web app. To even test them, you need to download a desktop or mobile app (whichever is available). They are included here for anyone who wants the total opposite of Slack.
- Patchwork (AGPLv3): an app for the P2P ("distributed") social network using the SSB (Secure Scuttlebutt) protocol. Desktop apps are available for GNU/Linux, Mac, and Windows. There is also an Android/Linux app for SSB called Manyverse (MPLv2).
Stalled or Abandoned?
- GroupServer (ZPLv2.1): Demo available at OnlineGroups.net. Mailing lists that can also be used like forums, using the searchable archive website. Developed by OnlineGroups, which is operated by a private company called Fiorenza Limited, based in Aotearoa (NZ). Downsides: no HTTPS, little sign of active maintenance over the last year or two.
Free code Slack-a-likes that seem to have been started and then abandoned. Included here for completeness, and in case studying the code may help someone:
- Candy ("MIT"): web client for XMPP, the only one I'm aware of to add WebRTC support. Was handed over to the Adhearsion Foundation before development ceased.
- Kaiwa ("MIT"): web client for XMPP. Some activity carried on in a fork by GH user ForNeVeR, but that seems inactive since 2018.
- Let's Chat ("MIT"): Compatible with XMPP/ MUC (see above), so a Let's Chat server can be accessed from any XMPP client, but doesn't federate with other XMPP servers. Abandoned by developers in about 2018.
Mainly blog pieces pointing out the problems with Slack, especially for open source communities, and in some cases suggesting replacements:
- 2015: 'Self-Hosted Team Chat Options and Alternatives' - Andrei Soroker and Niral Patel, SameRoom blog
- 2015: 'Please don't use Slack for FOSS projects' - Drew DeVault's blog
- 2015: 'So Yeah We Tried Slack… and We Deeply Regretted It' - FreeCodeCamp blog
- 2016: 'Slack, I’m Breaking Up with You' - Samuel Hulick's blog
- 2016: 'How Slack Can Hurt Your Teams Productivity' - Ben Bartling's blog
- 2016: 'Software Slack smackback: There's no IRC in team (software), say open-sourcers' - Scott Gilbertson, The Register
- 2017: 'Goodbye Slack and hello open-source messaging platform' - Wilhelm, Santiment blog
- 2017: 'Why Slack is inappropriate for open source communications' - Dave Cheney's blog
- 2017: 'Open source alternatives to Slack for team chat' - Jason Baker, OpenSource.com
- 2018: 'Why Slack is better, and why open communities shouldn't use it' - Dave Lane's blog
- 2018: 'Death By a Thousand Pings: The Hidden Side of Using Slack' - Alicia Liu's blog
- 2019: '[https://www.huffpost.com/entry/slack-is-bad-for-privacy_l_5d0bdc05e4b0aa375f49aa23 Slack Is Bad, Actually' - Monica Torres, Huffington Post