Planetary Economics

From P2P Foundation Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Description

Tenna Harbo:

"planetary economics aligns itself with overarching principles of Earth system science that understand our planet as a “single, complex, adaptive system, driven by the diverse interactions between energy, matter and organisms” (Steffen et al. 2020). Put differently, one might say that Earth system science adapts a holistic approach to earth as one big ecosystem comprising multiple, various ecosystems. Planetary economics would adopt a similar logic to its perception of the economy—namely, as a social system comprising multiple subsystems that are extremely context dependent yet interwoven and globally connected. In this regard, the planetary offers a new scale on which to narrate human agency, in addition to the already existing ones such as “geophysical force, political agent, bearer of rights and author of actions,” as Chakrabarty (2009) describes them. We cannot understand the entanglement of human and geohistory, he says, since it would demand thinking of “human agency on multiple and incommensurable scales at once” (cited in Coen 2016, p. 307). Conversely, Deborah Coen refuses to accept incommensurability between human and planetary scales. It is our duty to acquire what Vernadsky called the cosmic perspective, which makes clear mankind’s duties to one another and the nonhuman world (2016, 321). Scaling, Coen says, is the act of mediating between different systems of measurement, formal or informal, designed to apply to different slices of the phenomenal world (Coen 2016, 312). This entails a process of learning and, importantly, revising our judgments of things’ significance and letting go of certain attachments. And that, ultimately, remains an ethical process.

Planetary economics means fundamentally altering our perception of how we teach, practice, and think economics from the current landscape of schools, or silos, to an ecosystem of multiple systems, approaches, subjects, and outcomes. Imagine a sphere made up of temporal, spatial, and topical axes. In combination with a wide array of approaches and foci, a full ecosystem unfolds. Each point on this “globe” represents a unique “slice of the phenomenal world,” discernible by specific contexts as well as methodological and theoretical choices. Each research question therefore yields a specific set of coordinates, if you will, in that sphere. To accurately draw the contours of our ecosystem of knowledge, we must reflect upon our stance, approach, and degree of scaling. Rather than simply acknowledging identity markers or stating, “I am a white, middle-class woman,” informed positionality means positioning oneself in relation to theoretical frameworks, methodology, and historical and structural context while being aware of the relational dynamics of it. Informed positionality inherently follows the act of scaling and actively counters the positivist epistemology in economics. In fact, alternative schools that challenge the foundational principles of economics already practice a high degree of informed positionality. If fully integrated, it could ensure an ethical, context-sensitive economics able to include multiple experiences and knowledges."

(https://online.ucpress.edu/gp/article/6/1/144981/213644/Planetary-Economics-Embracing-Epistemological?)


More information

Boulding, K. E. 2011. The Economics of the Coming Spaceship Earth. RFF Press.

Crépin, Anne-Sophie, and Carl Folke. 2015. “The Economy, The Biosphere and Planetary Boundaries: Towards Biosphere Economics.” International Review of Environmental and Resource Economics 8 (1): 57–100. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1561/​101.00000066.

Tansel, Cemal Burak, and Lisa Tilley. 2024. “Reproducing Socio-Ecological Life from below: Towards a Planetary Political Economy of the Global Majority.” Review of International Studies 50 (3): 514–33. https:/​/​doi.org/​10.1017/​S0260210524000251.

* Article: Planetary Economics: Embracing Epistemological Pluralism for a New Knowledge Ecology. By Tenna Harbo. Global Perspectives (2025) 6 (1): 144981. doi

URL = https://online.ucpress.edu/gp/article/6/1/144981/213644/Planetary-Economics-Embracing-Epistemological?

"This essay examines the epistemological implications of planetary economics, a concept that integrates planetary boundaries with epistemological pluralism. It explores how the planetary scale could reshape economic knowledge production, fostering a new knowledge ecology. Emphasizing the tension between neoclassical economic models and complex Earth system science, the essay illustrates the incommensurability of neoclassical economics’ monolithic dominance with our pressing environmental crisis. Adding to a long line of calls for pluralism in economics, the essay argues for an active use of scaling and informed positionality to accommodate the integration of diverse methods, theories, and topics to create economics with a purpose."