Design as a Research Commons

From P2P Foundation Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

* Special Issue: Le design et ses pratiques, volet 3. Une affaire de communs. Catherine Chomarat-Ruiz (ed.). DAMpress journal.

URL = https://journal.dampress.org/words/le-design-et-ses-pratiques-volet-3-communs-et-commun-critique/presentation


Description

By Z.Ai, prompted by Michel Bauwens:

"built from a 2024–2025 seminar in théorie critique du design at Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne. M2 students conducted ~26 structured interviews (biography → encounter with the communs → their origins → the idea of a research commons). The driving question: what would a "commun critique de recherche" in design look like — a commons uniting designers, researchers and users in a tiers-lieu — and what do working designers actually make of the commons?

1. A shared definition — commons are a process, not a resource

Almost everyone insists that a commons is not just a shared pool of things. Lilian Ricaud gives the most-quoted formulation: a commons is "un équilibre entre une ressource, une communauté et un ensemble de règles partagées" — resource + community + governance. This traces back to Elinor Ostrom (vs. Hardin's "tragedy of the commons") and Dardot & Laval, and several interviewees prefer the verb to the noun: commoning ("il n'y a pas de commun, il faut le composer" — Théo Mouzard, after Latour). Rémi Astruc adds a useful distinction: le Commun (singular, an aspiration) vs. les communs (plural, concrete struggles over reappropriation).


2. Where designers say the commons come from

Activism and éducation populaire, not design theory: altermondialisme, Ne Pas Plier, unemployed movements (Nicolas Filloque); feminist and hacker ethics (Chloé Desmoineaux, Pola Noury); the logiciel libre and hackerspace milieu (Camille Bosqué).

Vernacular savoir-faire: auto-construction, participatory building, landscape practice (Marie Compagnon, Léo Pouliquen, Damien Grava) — "we've been doing commons since the beginning, before the word was fashionable" (Grava).

A response to suffering and loss of meaning: moderne solitude (Christophe Laurens), the destruction of lien au lieu by hyperindustrialization (Ludovic Duhem), the utilisateur-consommateur's demand for pouvoir d'agir (Compagnon).

Or simply pleasure: Michel Briand dissents from the suffering narrative — commons are born "du plaisir de coopérer, de faire ensemble en partage". Ecology and the finite world: Bosqué's communs négatifs (Monnin/Landivar — even toxic waste is an inherited common), Duhem's design écosocial, Elsenberger's "we are all reliés".


3. What design brings to the commons

Aesthetics first: Astruc's key claim — "pas de politique des communs sans une vision esthétique de ceux-ci"; design is directly engaged there.

Sharing the tools, not just the results: putting design instruments into common use turns publics into co-authors (Compagnon); open design as knowledge-sharing against capitalization (Desmoineaux).

Making local innovations transmissible: documenting "creative communities" so a one-off local idea becomes usable by others — collaborative services as commons, services publics collaboratifs (François Jegou); protocols and transmitted plans (Soumaya Nader).

Reclaiming public space: the commons as giving public space back to those who live it against visual pollution and privatization (Malte Martin); users as maîtres d'ouvrage (Grava); the droit à la ville of marginalized people, with their tacit knowledge and memories as the commons (Cristian Campagnaro).


4. What the commons bring to design

An economic model coherent with design écosocial — commons as a credible alternative for young designers (Duhem).

A feminist correction: via Silvia Federici, Pauline Gourlet argues that transposing commons onto design objects loses the dimension of reproduction/care — the "angle mort" that must be reintegrated into design for commons to be truly emancipatory.

A democratic widening: "Le design est trop important pour être laissé aux designers" (Ricaud) — equip citizens, not just professionals; commons must be oppositionnels (Bosqué, Delprat), a political act questioning private property (Grava, Mouzard's anti-neoliberal reading via Harvey).


5. A remarkably shared critical vocabulary

The designers converge on sharp warnings:

Pseudo-participation: "démocratie washing" (Zammit), "inclusion de façade", participation as "a checkbox in an Excel table" (Gourlet), "consultation cosmétique" (Compagnon), "participatif-washing" (Ricaud). Recuperation: "communs" as mot valise emptied by politicians and firms (Grava); open ≠ commons — what is open can be captured (Gourlet); open source ≠ libre — Google uses open source without creating commons (Ricaud).

Distrust of the consecrated infrastructures: FabLabs as "grant-grabbing geeks" (Zammit) or subsidy-suckers, tiers-lieux risking gentrification and the "effet vitrine" (Noury), an elitist "palette + récup" aesthetic in poor neighborhoods (Martin), fashion effects ("le FabLab à toutes les sauces", Bosqué).

Material obstacles: copyright and droits d'auteur (Briand's "freins culturels", Elsenberger, Filloque), and the precondition almost everyone implies — free time ("la libération du temps", Marcelline Bonneau).


6. Conditions for a commons to stay alive

Briand: a commons is alive only while it is animated — "ce n'est pas centraliser, c'est animer" — plus documentation and "le compostage des idées" (dead commons fertilize others, also Ricaud's compostabilité, Nader's protocols). Noury: commons places must be spaces of soin mutuel. Gourlet: "ce n'est pas le lieu qui compte, mais la situation" — commoning over the commons. Jegou: commons must eventually find economic models or they s'essoufflent.


7. The verdict on the hypothetical research tiers-lieu (the issue's closing question)

A real spectrum: already living it — Briand (Ti Lab, La MYNE, Open Factory), Desmoineaux (FluidSpace hacklab), Grava (Fab in Roubaix), Nader (Les Bains Douches), Campagnaro (it already exists in care settings). Yes, with conditions — Compagnon, Pouliquen, Astruc (needs another relation to knowledge, "ni expert ni ignorant"), Duhem (only if it embodies a critical design écosocial), Elsenberger, Villien. Skeptical or no — Zammit, Gourlet ("the situation, not the place"), Filloque (repair'cafés, recycleries and ateliers vélo are already doing this, and people are leaving the university for them), Mouzard (too abstract, risks being bourgeois/elitist — the real question is "comment s'adresser à tout le monde"), Bonneau, Noury.