Blockchain Proofs
Directory
- Proof of Value
- Proof-of-Movement
- Proof of Work ; Proof-of-Work-by-Renewable-Energy
- Proof of Existence
- Proof of Stake; Delegated Proof of Stake; Leased Proof of Stake
- Proof of Cooperation
- Proof of Importance
Discussion
Matthew Hutchinson:
"Proof of Stake and Delegated Proof of Stake systems have been heralded to be better than Bitcoin’s Proof of Work mining algorithm by reducing energy costs and significantly increasing transaction times but one problem still remains with those three consensus systems; plutocracy or ‘Rule of the Rich’.
Bitcoin’s Proof of Work system relies on the collective hashing power of the network to secure Bitcoins. It was intentionally designed to be resource intensive and difficult so that block times would remain relatively stable and so many miners would have the chance to solve the Proof of Work problem. But the problem with Proof of Work is that specialized machines have been created specifically for Bitcoin mining and now Bitcoin mining is no longer possible using your personal computer. Entire companies have sprung up around Bitcoin mining and have sunk vast amounts of fiat into their operations to increase their mining rate. These companies have pushed any regular user out of Bitcoin mining because of the sheer hashing power that they possess; a regular home computer just can’t keep up. Over time, Bitcoin has become almost centralized, with the vast majority of Bitcoins being mined by about 6 companies. In order for someone to become a miner now and compete with those 6, they would have to sink a large amount of money into a Bitcoin mining setup. With a single ASCII machine being about $2000 (or more), and having a requirement of dozens or more machines to be profitable, it’s easy to see that it’s not a cheap endeavor. It’s something that only the rich could jump into; an environment ripe for plutocracy.
Proof of Stake was invented to fix Proof of Work’s shortcomings. Proof of Stake is a democratic system that doesn’t require solving a hard math problem with computer calculations; instead it allows users to vote on practically everything within the blockchain; system variables, Witnesses (what ‘miners’ are called in PoS), system changes and proposals, etc… Proof of Stake delivers on a lot of benefits and can accomplish a lot of things but there’s a key flaw that’s right in the name: Stake. Voters in a Proof of Stake system must have stake to vote and their vote’s weight is the same as the stake they have. This means those with a large amount of stake could easily consolidate power and shutout any competing voice that doesn’t have the stake to back it up; the very definition of a plutocracy." (https://www.exeblock.com/proof-of-plutocracy/)