Mode Of Production Shootout: Difference between revisions

Latest revision as of 22:44, 9 February 2019

Any answer ending with a question mark (?) is tentative/guessed. If you know a better answer, please repair it.

List of Qualifiers

Add suggestions for better qualifiers here, or just change them yourself if you are confident:

Barriers to Entry
Control of Physical Sources
Control of Virtual Sources
Cost Recovery for Wages
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
Distribution of Land Tax funds
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
Who owns the product?

Capitalist

Barriers to Entry
- An entreprenuer must begin a whole new business to compete
Control of Physical Sources
- Split among Owners of Physical Sources weighted by ownership %
Control of Virtual Sources
- Copyright and Patent holders
Cost Recovery for Wages
- Workers reverse-bid to Owners
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
- Consumer pays full price, including Profit and becomes private Owner
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
- User pays Rent at what market will bear
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
- User pays city and county 'officials' weighted against improvement (regular property tax)
Distribution of Land Tax funds
- City and County 'officials' spend on projects as they see fit.
Cost Recovery Virtual Sources
- Tribute to Copyright or Patent holders
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- Split among Owners of Physical Sources weighted by ownership %
Who owns the product?
- Split among Owners of Physical Sources weighted by ownership %

Copyfarleft

Barriers to Entry
Control of Physical Sources
- All assets shared equally among all Owners?
Control of Virtual Sources
- Same as Capitalist?
Cost Recovery for Wages
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
Distribution of Land Tax funds
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
- Same as Capitalist?
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- Split equally among all workers?
Who owns the product?

Neocommercialization

Barriers to Entry
Control of Physical Sources
- All assets shared equally among all Owners?
Control of Virtual Sources
- Free?
Cost Recovery for Wages
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
Distribution of Land Tax funds
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
- Free?
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- Split equally among all workers?
Who owns the product?

Peerconomy

Barriers to Entry
- If you pick up tasks which a project needs to have handled, you become a member of the project. If you want to start a new project, you have to find sufficient other people willing to produce what you want to produce.
Control of Physical Sources
- Controlled by those who use them. Resources are available for usage for those who want them—for free, if there is enough of a resource for all who want it, otherwise those who are ready to contribute most effort will get them.
Control of Virtual Sources
- Free
Cost Recovery for Wages
- There are no wages, but the effort to get what you want is shared: if you spend effort for others, others will spend effort for you.
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
- The amount of effort required to produce an object is contributed by those want to use it. If there are more demands for some object than can be satisfied, those ready to spend most effort will get it—the additionally spent effort will be distributed among all produced objects (making them all slightly cheaper).
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
- Same as above, but effort to contribute can be shared by those who use an object over time.
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
- Land and all other resources are available for usage for those who want them—for free, if there is enough of a resource for all who want it, otherwise those who are ready to contribute most effort will get them. The contributed effort will be distributed among all produced objects (making them all slightly cheaper).
Distribution of Land Tax funds
- There are no taxes.
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
- Produced information goods are free. The effort required to produce them can be shared among those who like to have them just like any other effort.
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- There is no profit. "Price above cost" (effort required for getting a good surmounting the effort required for producing it) is distributed among all produced objects (making them all slightly cheaper).
Who owns the product?
- There is no ownership, only usage (possession).

Peer Production

Barriers to Entry
- Physical costs of each Peer Node?

Control of Physical Sources
- Each Peer controls only his own physical property? Do peers ever co-own physical assets? How are collective holdings governed?

Control of Virtual Sources
- Open? Free? GPL?

Cost Recovery for Wages
- Can Wages play a part in a Peer Economy?

Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
- Consumer pays full price, including Profit and becomes private Owner?

Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
- Banner ads?

Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
- ?

Distribution of Land Tax funds
- ?

Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
- ?

Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- ?

Who owns the product?
- ?

Utilicontributism

Barriers to Entry
Control of Physical Sources
- Property Commons: Entitlement shared, Ownership is "Guardianship," and subject to Use "rent"
Control of Virtual Sources
- A Vested Commons
Cost Recovery for Wages
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
- User pays global officials weighted against current holdings?
Distribution of Land Tax funds
- Distributed to all humans on the planet weighted by % each use is not currently using?
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
- Free?
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- To service-provider(s) / worker(s) of service
Who owns the product?

Property Left

Barriers to Entry
- Each Object Consumer gains controlling ownership in collectively owned Physical Sources whenever they pay Price Above Cost (the current owners will grow the business by buying new Physical Sources needed for that type of Object, and those investments will 'vest' to the paying consumer at some later date.)
Control of Physical Sources
- Same as Capitalist
Control of Virtual Sources
- Free
Cost Recovery for Wages
- Same as Capitalist
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
- Same as Capitalist
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
- Same as Capitalist
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
Distribution of Land Tax funds
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
- Free
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
- Investment in more Physical Sources to eventually vest to user who paid it.
Who owns the product?
- Same as Capitalist.

Economic Democracy

Barriers to Entry
Control of Physical Sources
Control of Virtual Sources
Cost Recovery for Wages
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
Distribution of Land Tax funds
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
Who owns the product?

United Diversity

Barriers to Entry
Control of Physical Sources
Control of Virtual Sources
Cost Recovery for Wages
Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
Distribution of Land Tax funds
- 50% into pot for re-investment, 50% split among owners weighted by % past contributions?
Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
Profit, 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
Who owns the product?

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-'''This has become quite a mess to read.  Any suggestions on how to make it better?'''
+Any answer ending with a question mark (?) is tentative/guessed. If you know a better answer, please repair it.
-*  How about: When a cell contains too much text, fill that cell with a '''link''' to a page that contains the full explaination?  For instance, the link [[Barriers To Entry - Property Left]] would be placed in that cell, and that new page would then contain the text currently overpopulating that cell...
+== List of Qualifiers ==
+''Add suggestions for better qualifiers here, or just change them yourself if you are confident:''
-* Maybe just take this all out of a table and make it a list of lists?
-: ''I second the "list of lists" option.'' --[[User:ChristianS|ChristianS]] 08:34, 16 March 2008 (PDT)
-:: Christian, I started trying to make the list and didn't like the row titles.  See [[Talk:Mode_Of_Production_Shootout]] for the current list and please suggest better titles.  In other words, what 'qualifiers' should each Mode of Production be interrogated?
-:: For now I also made the list of lists, but can change them quickly (using Emacs) if we decided on better titles. -- [[User:Ownut|Ownut]] 11:29, 16 March 2008 (PDT)
-::: Qualifies look ok to me—I now replaced the table by your list of lists from the discussion page. --[[User:ChristianS|ChristianS]] 02:32, 22 March 2008 (PDT)
-----
-Any cell ending with a question mark (?) should be considered tenative.  If you know the answer, please repair that cell.
-Add suggestions for better row titles here, or just chage them yourself if you are confident:
-* Change row titled "ROW TITLE" to "NEW ROW TITLE"
-* Add row titled "NEW ROW TITLE"
-----
+* Barriers to Entry
+* Control of Physical Sources
+* Control of Virtual Sources
+* Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
+* Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
+* Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
+* Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
+* Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
+* Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
+* [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
+* Who owns the product?
@@ Line 27: / Line 20: @@
 * Barriers to Entry
 ** An entreprenuer must begin a whole new business to compete
-* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+* Control of Physical Sources
-** Split among Owners of [[Physical Sources]] weighted by ownership %
+** Split among Owners of Physical Sources weighted by ownership %
-* Control of [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Control of Virtual Sources
 ** Copyright and Patent holders
 * Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
 ** Workers reverse-bid to Owners
-* Cost Recovery for permanent use of [[Object]]
+* Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
-** User pays what market will bear, User becomes private Owner
+** Consumer pays full price, including [[Profit]] and becomes private [[Owner]]
 * Cost Recovery for temporary use of [[Object]]
 ** User pays [[Rent]] at what market will bear
@@ Line 40: / Line 33: @@
 ** User pays city and county 'officials' weighted against improvement (regular property tax)
 * Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
-City and County 'officials' spend on projects as they see fit.
+** City and County 'officials' spend on projects as they see fit.
 * Cost Recovery [[Virtual Sources]]
 ** Tribute to Copyright or Patent holders
 * [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
-** Split among Owners of [[Physical Sources]] weighted by ownership %
+** Split among Owners of Physical Sources weighted by ownership %
 * Who owns the product?
-** Split among Owners of [[Physical Sources]] weighted by ownership %
+** Split among Owners of Physical Sources weighted by ownership %
 === [[Copyfarleft]] ===
 * Barriers to Entry
-* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+* Control of Physical Sources
-All assets shared equally among all Owners?
+** All assets shared equally among all Owners?
-* Control of [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Control of Virtual Sources
 ** Same as Capitalist?
 * Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
@@ Line 59: / Line 52: @@
 * Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
 * Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
-* Cost Recovery: [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
 ** Same as Capitalist?
 * [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
@@ Line 67: / Line 60: @@
 === [[Neocommercialization]] ===
 * Barriers to Entry
-* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+* Control of Physical Sources
-All assets shared equally among all Owners?
+** All assets shared equally among all Owners?
-* Control of [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Control of Virtual Sources
 ** Free?
 * Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
-* Cost Recovery for permanent use of [[Object]]
+* Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
-* Cost Recovery for temporary use of [[Object]]
+* Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
 * Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
 * Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
-* Cost Recovery: [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
 ** Free?
 * [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
 ** Split equally among all workers?
 * Who owns the product?
 === [[Peerconomy]] ===
 * Barriers to Entry
 ** If you pick up tasks which a project needs to have handled, you become a member of the project. If you want to start a new project, you have to find sufficient other people willing to produce what you want to produce.
-* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+* Control of Physical Sources
 ** Controlled by those who use them. Resources are available for usage for those who want them—for free, if there is enough of a resource for all who want it, otherwise those who are ready to contribute most effort will get them.
-* Control of [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Control of Virtual Sources
 ** Free
 * Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
-** There are no wages, but the ''effort'' to get what you want is ''shared''** if you spend effort for others, others will spend effort for you.
+** There are no wages, but the ''effort'' to get what you want is ''shared:'' if you spend effort for others, others will spend effort for you.
 * Cost Recovery for permanent use of [[Object]]
 ** The amount of effort required to produce an object is contributed by those want to use it. If there are more demands for some object than can be satisfied, those ready to spend most effort will get it—the additionally spent effort will be distributed among all produced objects (making them all slightly cheaper).
@@ Line 99: / Line 93: @@
 * Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
 ** There are no taxes.
-* Cost Recovery: [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
 ** Produced information goods are free. The effort required to produce them can be shared among those who like to have them just like any other effort.
 * [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
@@ Line 105: / Line 99: @@
 * Who owns the product?
 ** There is no ownership, only usage (possession).
+=== [[Peer Production]] ===
+[[Peer Production]]
+* Barriers to Entry
+** Physical costs of each Peer Node?
+* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+** Each Peer controls only his own physical property?  Do peers ever co-own physical assets?  How are collective holdings governed?
+* Control of Virtual Sources
+** Open?  Free?  GPL?
+* Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
+** Can Wages play a part in a Peer Economy?
+* Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
+** Consumer pays full price, including [[Profit]] and becomes private [[Owner]]?
+* Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
+** Banner ads?
+* Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
+** ?
+* Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
+** ?
+* Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
+** ?
+* [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
+** ?
+* Who owns the product?
+** ?
 === [[Utilicontributism]] ===
 * Barriers to Entry
-* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+* Control of Physical Sources
-** [[Property Commons]]**Entitlement shared, Ownership is "Guardianship," and subject to Use "rent"
+** [[Property Commons]]: Entitlement shared, Ownership is "Guardianship," and subject to Use "rent"
-* Control of [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Control of Virtual Sources
 ** A [[Vested Commons]]
 * Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
-* Cost Recovery for permanent use of [[Object]]
+* Cost Recovery for permanent use of Object
-* Cost Recovery for temporary use of [[Object]]
+* Cost Recovery for temporary use of Object
 * Cost Recovery for Exclusive use of Land
 ** User pays global officials weighted against current holdings?
 * Distribution of Land [[Tax]] funds
 ** Distributed to all humans on the planet weighted by % each use is not currently using?
-* Cost Recovery: [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Cost Recovery: Virtual Sources
 ** Free?
 * [[Profit]], 'surplus', or "Price above cost"
@@ Line 128: / Line 159: @@
 * Barriers to Entry
 ** Each [[Object]] Consumer gains controlling ownership in collectively owned Physical Sources whenever they pay [[Price Above Cost]] (the current owners will grow the business by buying new Physical Sources needed for that type of Object, and those investments will 'vest' to the paying consumer at some later date.)
-* Control of [[Physical Sources]]
+* Control of Physical Sources
 ** Same as Capitalist
-* Control of [[Virtual Sources]]
+* Control of Virtual Sources
 ** Free
 * Cost Recovery for [[Wage]]s
@@ Line 147: / Line 178: @@
 ** Same as Capitalist.
-=== [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_democracy Economic Democracy]] ===
+=== [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_democracy Economic Democracy] ===
 * Barriers to Entry
 * Control of [[Physical Sources]]