Post-Left Theory
* Book: Post-Left Theory: Beyond Marxism, Anarchism, and Vibes. Tony Chamas and David McKerracher. 2026.
URL = https://https://postlefttheory.com/
"works of rigorous theory that aim to make sense of the collapse of the left and why people drift away from it."
Description
Tony Chamas:
"Together, the essays encompass the broader theme of post-left theory. What distinguishes that theory, and the theoretical work Dave and I are doing, is that it breaks from the left’s big Other, which Dave describes in his introduction as “the imagined authority whose approval you are unconsciously working to win, the audience in your head that quietly sets the outer limit of what you are permitted to think.”
It truly is neither left nor right, in the sense that it doesn’t exclude itself from either side. We tend to lean left in some ways and conservative in others, and I might lean more left than Dave does. In the introduction, Dave describes me as someone who still writes to the Left, documenting “what the Left would have to understand to become a majoritarian force again,” while he writes about it “the way you write about a country you’ve emigrated from.” As he puts it, “This tension could be read as the co-authors disagreeing about what the book is, but I argue it is the opposite: it is the book’s engine.
...
As Dave explains in his introduction, we settled on the title Post-Left Theory because “while there have been ‘Post-Left’ figures and moments, there has never been a concerted effort to understand the situation from a genuinely post-left position.” Reaching a political synthesis adequate to the present means getting beyond the binaries of Left and Right”.
...
Post-Left Theory does not present a program for a movement. This is not a manifesto. Within these pages will be found no grand solutions, no prefabricated identity for consumers to wear. What this book supplies its reader is something more akin to a grenade to detonate one’s presuppositional coordinates. The disagreements within and between the pieces in this volume will force you to carve out your own position, and it will be your own, because you cannot read this book and walk away the same. Free yourself from the Party Line, the checkboxes of what can or cannot be said, and the cloistered confines of a captured dead end. What opens here is a horizon on a frontier."
(https://1dimereview.substack.com/p/my-new-book-is-out?)
Contents
Narrative
"The book is organized around these broader themes, in four parts:
- Framing Post-Left Theory;
- Why Not Marxism, Anarchism, Communism;
- The Actually Existing Left; and
- The Frontier.
Amongst the essays:
- “The Phantom of Patriarchy,”
- “The Cosmopolitan Delusion,”
- “The Leftist Industrial Complex,”
- “The Self-Contained Opposition Factory,”
- “Marxism as Accelerationism,”
- “Actually Existing Marxism”
- “The Suicide of the Left.”
Those five are only part of my half of the book. In Part One, “The Left-Right Binary Is Obsolete” asks what “leftism” even means today, and “The Culture War Is the Class War” lays out my theory of the two lefts. That one is also the fourth and final essay in my Genealogy of Wokeism series, though you don’t need to have read the earlier parts. Part Two collects my essays on Marxism: “Actually Existing Marxism”; “Marxism’s Sorelian Myths,” on communism as a faith for the faithless; “The Myth of Marxist Internationalism”; “Marxism as Accelerationism,” on how communism accelerated capitalism; and “You Probably Aren’t a Marxist,” on why “old leftists” are post-leftists in denial. Alongside my favorites in Part Three, “The Myth of ‘The Movement’” proposes a new political strategy, “On Left-Liberal Conformism” looks at thought taboos and subconscious self-censorship in urban-progressive spaces, and “Anti-Social Socialists” is about how the left became a freak show. All three of those, along with both of my Part One essays, started here on 1Dime Review.
My last essay in the book is “Re-thinking Socialism and Class in the 21st Century.” Class conflict is the one thing I think Marxism does emphasize; its theory of class, however, I believe to be outdated. In its place I offer an alternative theory of class and socialism for our century, which I develop above all in that chapter."
(https://1dimereview.substack.com/p/my-new-book-is-out?)
ToC
Part One: Framing Post-Left Theory
• Introduction, David McKerracher
• 1. The Left-Right Binary Is Obsolete, Tony Chamas
• 2. It’s 2026 and You’re Still “Left Without the L,” David McKerracher
• 3. The Culture War Is the Class War, Tony Chamas
Part Two: Why Not Marxism, Anarchism, Communism
• 4. Why I Am Not an Anarchist, David McKerracher
• 5. Actually Existing Marxism, Tony Chamas
• 6. Why I Am (Still) Not a Marxist, David McKerracher
• 7. Marxism’s Sorelian Myths, Tony Chamas
• 8. The Myth of Marxist Internationalism, Tony Chamas
• 9. Don’t Read Settlers, David McKerracher
• 10. Marxism as Accelerationism, Tony Chamas
• 11. You Probably Aren’t a Marxist, Tony Chamas
Part Three: The Actually Existing Left
• 12. Lefter Than Thou, David McKerracher
• 13. The Myth of “The Movement,” Tony Chamas
• 14. It’s Easier to Imagine the End of the World Than a big Other That’s Neither Left Nor Right, David McKerracher
• 15. On Left-Liberal Conformism, Tony Chamas
• 16. Why I Am Not Anti-PMC, David McKerracher
• 17. Anti-Social Socialists, Tony Chamas
• 18. Why I Hate the Rebel Priest Class, David McKerracher
• 19. The Leftist Industrial Complex, Tony Chamas
• 20. The Cosmopolitan Delusion, Tony Chamas
• 21. Chapo Trap House Hyperstitioned Chud the Builder, David McKerracher
• 22. The Suicide of the Left, Tony Chamas
• 23. History and Function of “Conspiracy Theory” as a Disqualifying Label, David McKerracher
• 24. The Self-Contained Opposition Factory, Tony Chamas
• 25. The Phantom of Patriarchy, Tony Chamas
Part Four: The Frontier
• 26. Timenergy, Energytime, Feral Time, Scholabor, David McKerracher in conversation with Tyler Murphy
• 27. The Natality Pill, David McKerracher
• 28. Nature, Nurture, Natality, David McKerracher
• 29. Postscript on N3, David McKerracher
• 30. Re-thinking Socialism and Class in the 21st Century, Tony Chamas
• 31. Based Neo-Jeffersonianism, David McKerracher
Afterword
• Postscript on Post-Left Theory, David McKerracher
Discussion
My Five Favourite Essays
Tony Chamas:
"If you’re not sure where to start, start with these. They’re my five favorites, and all five are in Part Three, The Actually Existing Left.
“The Suicide of the Left” Cultural Progressivism as an Ideology of Late Capitalism
The usual story about the left’s failure is one of political murder: it was killed by McCarthyism, crushed by capital, infiltrated by the state and betrayed by timid liberals. There is a rational kernel of truth in those stories, but they don’t explain why the left keeps choosing ideas that estrange it from the people it claims to represent. My thesis is that the left was not simply defeated; it killed itself. Cultural leftism gained institutional influence at precisely the time left-wing economic agendas lost theirs, so the Overton window moved left on culture and right on economics, and cultural leftism fit the individualist consumer logic of late capitalism, even helping to accelerate it by becoming a core part of the dominant ideology. The title is a triple entendre: the suicide of the left as a political force, the civilizational suicide it helps rationalize, and, partly metaphorically, the suicide of leftists themselves, with self-destructive ways of living recast as politics, identity or liberation. The essay is written for the leftists who want to build a better society, not the ones who want to destroy this one in the hope that something better follows: “It is not an obituary for the left or a celebration of its enemies. It is a warning to a movement that has confused despair with insight, negation with radicalism, and destruction with change.”
“The Cosmopolitan Delusion” The Sociology of Liberal-Left Obliviousness
Why are leftists and liberals out of touch on so many of the same popular concerns, from mass migration and globalization to the reaction against the excesses of social progressivism, all of which they have largely ceded to the populist right? My answer is that the rootless cosmopolitan experience is central to it, and that on immigration above all, they are blinded by their own rootless cosmopolitanism. I know that term has an ugly, antisemitic history, and the essay confronts that history head-on, because I mean something very different from what the far right means by it. I am naming a sociological type that cuts across religions and ethnicities, anchored in class position, education and life experience: a professional-managerial and symbolic elite whose material conditions, social circles and moral outlook detach them from the everyday attachments, insecurities and grievances of most people. From there the essay works through the urban-rural and education divides, globalism as a luxury belief, and who actually benefits from immigration. As I put it in the conclusion, “The point of this essay is not to side with xenophobes against migrants, or with cosmopolitan elites against rooted peoples.” Both the liberal fantasy of a borderless world and the far-right fantasy of an ethnically purified nation are dead ends, and the rootless cosmopolitan “mistakes having no roots for having access to the universal, when the universal only exists in and through the particular: one becomes a citizen of the world by first being a citizen of somewhere.”
“The Phantom of Patriarchy” The Function of Actually Existing Feminism Today
Patriarchy is still discussed on much of the left as if it were an ever-present specter hanging over Western society, usually without anyone stopping to define what they mean by it. Questioning whether the West is still meaningfully patriarchal gets treated as if it were the same as denying that sexism, misogyny or discrimination still exist, but those are two different claims. Women obviously still face problems. The serious question is what institutions, laws and material relations actually make our social order patriarchal in any historically meaningful sense. Drawing on the French historical anthropologist Emmanuel Todd, I look at what patriarchy actually was, why it still appears to exist, and what replaced it: a market system that now governs intimate life and exploits men and women alike. None of this is an argument for restoring patriarchy. What I propose instead is what I call love within limits, and an end to a gender war fought in the shadow of a phantom: “The gender war ends not when one side wins but when both sides recognize the phantom for what it is, and turn their collective attention to the market system that exploits them both.”
“The Leftist Industrial Complex” The Incentives That Drive the Vampire Castle
Watch what happens when someone on the left offers even the mildest criticism of their own side. Within hours, the criticism is no longer being discussed; the critic is. This essay explains why, building on what Mark Fisher called the Vampire Castle. The leftist industrial complex is “a self-perpetuating, non-directed, non-conspiratorial ecosystem of impotent opposition.” Nobody needs to orchestrate it from above. Creators compete for attention inside a niche audience, algorithms reward engagement, subscribers reward affirmation, and professional networks punish anyone coded as reactionary or unsafe. Each person may be acting rationally, but together they produce an opposition with no incentive to understand or appeal to anyone beyond itself. “This is why the movement can decline while the industry grows.” Along the way I ask, “If the working class has no voice, whose voice are we hearing when left media claims to speak for it?” The last section asks: “How many times must you lose before you ask whether you are playing the game wrong?”
“The Self-Contained Opposition Factory”
When opposition in a democracy seems reliably neutralized, the most common explanation is conspiratorial: somebody is pulling the strings. My alternative is a theory I call contained opposition, which I first formulated in my master’s thesis at York University, explored in my video essay “Controlled Opposition” on the 1Dime channel, and develop most fully in my next forthcoming book with Sublation Media, Freedom to Change Nothing: Managed Democracy Explained, which is my solo book that I have been working on for nearly 4 years and announced on my channel nearly 2 years ago. To control something presupposes a hand on the lever. To contain something is to hold it within limits without necessarily directing it, the way a river is contained by its banks. Contained opposition is tolerated, even encouraged, because the institutional logic of the system it operates in reliably keeps it from accumulating real power; inverting Foucault, I argue that “where power is strong, there is resistance without power.” This essay applies the theory to the academy, the primary institutional base of the contemporary left, which trains “critics who cannot build, deconstructors who cannot synthesize, activists who cannot organize beyond campus boundaries.” Put more bluntly: “The left was allowed to control the universities while controlling nothing else, and this arrangement turns out to serve system stability perfectly.”