Great Escape

From P2P Foundation Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

= refers to specific historical transition periods that create exit possibilities from an old system. The first example would be the 15th cy. 'escape from feudalism'. Mark Whitaker argues we are now in a Second Great Escape period.

Source

This is from a book draft in progress entitled

* "The Glomos:Nested Global Ecoregions for Representative and Sustainable Living, By Mark D. Whitaker.

  1. Follow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/markdouglaswhitaker/
  2. Follow on ResearchGate: https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mark-Whitaker-2


Discussion

Mark Whitaker:

""So now another ‘great escape’, via a global decentralized digital media, makes this balanced and nested full public sphere durably available at all scales of communities for the first time since the early period of mass printing in Europe. However, unlike mass printing in Europe, the global digital and decentralized media is obviously worldwide, and it lacks mass market bias in content. Instead, any wider mass market in this digital medium only creates more decentralized technological nodes, making the decentralization and modularity stronger. Thus, within this digital media network, we only create more decentralized technological nodes via more mass markets instead of cauterizing our public spheres by mass market biased content anymore. Therefore, the great escape via a nested and balanced public sphere becomes durable for the first time in world history—as regional, national, and global deliberation starts to occur without a centralized way to censor or propagandize through it completely like before. It is in this wider nested and balanced public sphere that there can be a better push toward making a long-lived, representative, and sustainable national polity by full completed representation at all levels without unrepresentative and degradative agenda-gatekeeping in nations for the first time. Thus, this wider nested and balanced public sphere helps us create a completed national representation and is an aid the Glomos.

Let us summarize now what has been meant by the term ‘great escape’ used above.


A ‘great escape’ will be defined as

(1) a period of wider unconsolidated discussions and experimentations increasingly against past cultures and polities,

(2) aided by a fresh media change, that creates

(3) a wider public sphere of discussion between regional (smaller-scale cultures closer embedded with shared environmental conditions), national (larger shared linguistic/cultural community zones with generally less shared cross-regional environmental conditions), and universal (humanistic, generalized religious, generalized regional, generalized cultural, generalized environmental, and secular global) interests, which in turn

(4) encourages more representative and thus sustainable systemic challenges and alliances of rearrangement of leaderships and followers against past unrepresentative hegemonic arrangements, though hardly requires these more representative outcomes since outcomes still are dependent of course on the ongoing history of this interaction of more representative and sustainable forces versus more unrepresentative and degradative forces, instead of operating predictably.

In this way, media changes irregularly interrupt and change: past habits and behaviors in daily life, mental capacities, cultural leadership, economics, politics, and even frame what kinds of organizational designs work effectively over time, including states. The rest of this section concentrates on the importance of two media regime changes that led to these two great escapes, one nearly 600 years ago with the rise of mass printing in Europe in the 1450s and associated with the later invention of centralized nation states, and one happening in the early 21st century now worldwide with globally decentralized mobile technologies of telecommunications.

The current great escape brings an open question of what kind of nation states or polities will digitally develop from it with two extremes available: either collapsed nations and global technocracies that want to remain unrepresentative (that will fail to survive very long), or more fully representative and sustainable nations (by adopting more cross-regional confederative and sustainable forms within them and by embracing this more nested and balanced public sphere, instead of fighting these developments). So the future depends on the choices of aggregate national citizens and national leaderships from this point on. However, any continued unrepresentative national leaderships that are against such a wider, nested, and balanced public sphere will wreck the nation state—because their populations now have more autonomous capacities to form the futures they want by wider open debates. Meanwhile, any more representative national leaderships that embrace this wider balanced public sphere to survive will find a design model to renew their nations for greater longevity, representation, and sustainability in its economics, in its culture, and in its politics.

Some may be skeptical at this point that media regime changes have such wide influences on the trajectories of cultures and states. Therefore, let the following short points of fact be provided to a candid world. See if your skepticism and ambivalence turns to a double worry when you first realize the scale of what a novel media regime can do for changing trajectories of cultural transmissions and state (re)formations in general, and second, when you realize that we are just getting started in living within a global decentralized digital media of billions of nodes equitably distributed worldwide.

Picture this. In Europe, originally, book publishing meant only manuscript copies. Between 1400 to 1450, there were an estimated 7 million manuscript hand copies made, before mass printing. However, after mass printing, between 1450-1500, approximately 11 million books were mass printed in the first fifty years. After that, between 1500 and 1600, approximately 250 million books were mass printed. This is the magnitude of scale and change in the first ‘great escape’ that came from its publishing freedom, its encouragement to literacy, and its wider public sphere and later its mass market biased public sphere that both completely altered Europe forever in the 1500s. (See Chart 1 and 2 for these numbers charted across time).


The Second Great Escape

Now picture the second ‘great escape’ from global decentralized digital media and how its destabilizations and reformation are only at the beginning. Starting from zero smartphones in 2007, by 2019 there were an estimated 5 billion mobile phones and smartphones. By 2021, there were an estimated 6.37 billion mobile phones, with an estimated 5.31 billion unique mobile phone subscribers (Bank My Cell, 2023;We Are Social, 2022, xxxx). This was only fourteen years after the smartphone’s invention in 2007. By 2025, there were an estimated 5.78 billion unique mobile phone subscribers, with 6.04 billion people estimated to be using the Internet.

[We Are Social. 2025. DIGITAL 2026: Your ultimate guide to the evolving digital world. WeAreSocial.com (October 15) https://wearesocial.com/uk/blog/2025/10/digital-2026/; https://wearesocial.com/uk/blog/2025/10/digital-2026-global-overview-report/]

If there is to be a date for the beginning of this worldwide cultural and political reformation of all past ‘half complete’ nation states, for better (toward the Glomos) or for worse (toward global technocracy), it might be 2017. This is because 2017 was the first year in which the majority (50%+) of Internet experience was estimated to be mediated through smartphones globally (We Are Social / Hootsuite, 2017, xxxx).

So, if you believe that the highly divided cultural foment and social movement disturbances against current state policies are at an absurdly high level in 2026 that will surely recede, please reconsider the exponential beginning of the second ‘great escape’ that you are witnessing now. Only more representative and confederative leaderships than ever will survive by riding this wave of growing distributed representation. Otherwise, they will surely go under this wave and be forgotten. Think that we are less than 10 years into a world in which the global majority of media now flows through individually-selected, viral, and self-assembling communities of smartphone networks. Thus, our collective suffering under unrepresentative and degradative leaderships, polities, and policies held in untouchable stasis above us in ‘half complete’ nation states is at an end, because their past monopolies of easily censored and controlled state broadcasting and mass-market-biased corporate broadcasting are at an end. This is the beginning of an Ecological Reformation in all cultures, states, and other institutions worldwide within a more durably nested and balanced public sphere that is more representative for everyone at last. Plus, given that those over 5.78 billion electronically networked mobile and smartphone subscribers are rather equitably distributed around the world instead of only found in more developed countries of the world, [xxxx] this means the coming Ecological Reformation will be worldwide.

So, I think you may agree that we are just starting the second ‘great escape.’ For a comparison, the world in the 2020s is quite like Europe in the 1520s—the calm before the Reformation and 150 years of warfare because all factions wanted their own separate unrepresentative arrangements over others. Only from the Peace of Westphalia in 1648 did Europeans start to look back and see that their 150 years of fighting for many different unrepresentative versions of dominance did nothing for anyone except mutual destruction. So, now, let us try to avoid any potential future scenarios of another 150 years of incessant unrepresentative infighting by choosing the transition plan of the Glomos. We can avoid all the potential sufferings of this current ‘great escape’ while only accentuating its benefits if we reject unrepresentative goals and team up in more representative and nested accommodations—by adding more internal regional and cross-border representation concerns to past autonomous unrepresentative and degradative national politics, and by adding more local national representative concerns against unrepresentative global technocratic coups right now. However, history is always a systemic fight for thousands of years between those wanting more representative and sustainable changes of life versus more unrepresentative and centralized global technocracy. Now they are both attempting to use the same technological networks to their advantage. Only the Glomos plan has a positive outcome though.

So, this second ‘great escape’ is interrupting and pulling apart past nationally centralized mass media and past centralized nation states everywhere, in what has been called the triple ‘global digital storm’ of:

(1) a global digital economy,

(2) a global digital culture, and

(3) a global decentralized media. Plus, from the third point of a global decentralized media, this means the worldwide distributed scale of this global digital storm is having effects on resource mobilization in social movements that equally are more regionalizing, worldwide. This makes organizations in daily life more effective

(3a) toward raising regional capacities by digitally-assisted regional economies. Organizations equally become more effective

(3b) toward more fully representative regionalized cultural participation for fleshing out past ‘hollow’ centralized nation states, since digitally-assisted virtual communities now can build political capacities for real geographic regional communities to complain about and to act upon social and environmental risks dumped upon them in the past or the present by the centralized national politics. These added regional economic and cultural-political capacities can be added without having to be sponsored anymore by centralized media or centralized parties to air their grievances and to act on them for their own solutions. Organizations equally are made more effective

(3c) toward how a decentralized digital global media builds more regionally autonomous capacities of communication in production and distribution of media. This helps to develop more fully representative and deliberative economic, cultural, and political participation in regions, whether these regions are within nation states or even split across the borders of past nation states. Both kinds of regions were previously ignored and repressed subaltern and degraded regional interests and cross-border common interests and concerns. Plus, all kinds of national politics were previously ignored and repressed by a growing global technocratic edifice of unelected leaderships as well. All of these representative and sustainable forces are brought together in alliance in the Glomos plan.

As described later, the first great escape in the late 1400s into the early 1500 in mass printing only happened in a European context due to at least three other social European contexts around this media change that were missing in other regional civilizations’ inventions and uses of mass printing in the same period or even earlier. Meanwhile, the second great escape is happening worldwide because it is in a digital electronic form from the equitably distributed and global decentralized telecommunications of smartphones in the billions of units and users. This network of information and deliberation exists in the direct hands of the majority of people now on the planet from around 2019...."

(email October 2026, fragment from the draft of Glomos)