Talk:P2P Public Intellectuals

Michel, I notice you gave up on this list in 2012.

I'm inclined to agree there is little point in having a list which, if not kept updated, becomes misleading.

But there is one reason I can think of for having a list of this kind: a list of people, notable enough to feature in Wikipedia, for whom there are pages here on the P2PF Wiki.

This could then be a note pad for who we should have pages about, together with links to their wikipedia pages, and until we have a page, a line on why we should have one. On creating a page, then this line could be transferred as the headline of the Bio page.

Once we have a Bio page, there is no more need for links or information here.

We could have a similar policy on e.g. the economists page, or just merge them by having one page with different groupings in it.

Simon Grant (talk) 10:11, 10 February 2017 (UTC)